IPS-Eye-White
001orange

Section 10A .. The Contemporary Church/
Mysticism In The Church/ Contemplative Prayer

 

003whiteSection 10A The Contemporary Church   >   Doctrines of Demons     >     Mysticism   >   Contemplative Prayer

IPS-Header
Mysticism-Bg
 

 Contemplative Prayer... The Pioneers
Henri Nouwen

Carol Brooks

Hear the word which the LORD speaks to you, O house of Israel. Thus says the Lord, "Do not learn the way of the nations... (Jeremiah 10:1-2 NASB)

    Index To The Pioneers - Thomas Merton, Henri Nouwen, Brennan Manning, and Thomas Keating HERE

    Index To All Seven Chapters on Contemplative Prayer HERE

    Bible1-Bar

    Henri Nouwen (1932-1996)

    Introduction and Background

    Nouwen and Ecumenism

    Whatever Happened to Discernment?

    Henri Nouwen and Contemplative Prayer

    Nouwen and Eastern Religions
    Nouwen and Fr. Thomas Ryan, Andrew Harvey, and Eknath Easwaran

    Nouwen - Other
    Homosexuality
    Nouwen' Strange Fascination with Vincent Van Gogh

    Conclusion


    Introduction
    Henri Nouwen's website describes him as an "internationally renowned priest and author" and a "respected professor and beloved pastor"CP-Nouwen who wrote over 40 books on the spiritual life." They go on to say (Emphasis Added)

      He corresponded regularly in English, Dutch, German, French and Spanish with hundreds of friends and reached out to thousands through his Eucharistic celebrations, lectures and retreats. Since his death in 1996, ever-increasing numbers of readers, writers, teachers and seekers have been guided by his literary legacy. Nouwen's books have sold over 2 million copies and been published in over 22 languages"...

      His spirit lives on in the work of the Henri Nouwen Society, Henri Nouwen Stichting, the Henri Nouwen Trust, the Henri J. M. Nouwen Archives and Research Collection, and in all who live the spiritual values of communion, community and ministry, to which he dedicated his life". [01]


    Background
    Henri Nouwen was born in Holland in 1932 and ordained a Catholic priest in 1957. He studied psychology at the University of Nijmegen in The Netherlands, taught psychology for two years at Notre Dame (1966-68), and spent two years as a part-time professor at Harvard Divinity School (1983 -85).

    However, it was during the ten years he spent teaching at Yale Divinity School that he spent several months living a monastic life with Trappist monks at the Abbey of the Genesee in NY, and became a fellow at the Ecumenical Institute at Collegeville, Minnesota that brought him into contact with people of other faiths. It was also during this period that he began to write prolifically. Several of his over 40 books on spirituality, such as Way of the Heart, The Wounded Healer, Reaching Out etc. date from these years.

    Nouwen appeared to have found his calling when he spent a year in the original L’Arche community in Trosly-Breuil, France where people with intellectual disabilities and their care givers live together in community. In 1986 Henri Nouwen became  pastor of L'Arche Daybreak  near Toronto, Canada.

    However, there was a hugely important influence in Nouwen's life - Thomas Merton. Nouwen apparently admired Merton enough to write a book about him - Pray to live: Thomas Merton: A Contemplative Critic is an introduction to the thought of Thomas Merton with a five page bibliography of Merton's works at the back. Michael O' Laughlin says, (Emphasis Added)

      "Some new elements began to emerge in Nouwen's thinking when he discovered Thomas Merton. Merton opened up for Henri an enticing vista of the world of contemplation and a way of seeing not only God but also the world through new eyes. . . . If ever there was a time when Henri Nouwen wished to enter the realm of the spiritual masters or dedicate himself to a higher spiritual path, it was when he fell under the spell of Cistercian monasticism and the writings of Thomas Merton." [02]


    Nouwen and Ecumenism
    The Bible says

      Do not be bound together with unbelievers; for what partnership have righteousness and lawlessness, or what fellowship has light with darkness? Or what harmony has Christ with Belial, or what has a believer in common with an unbeliever? Or what agreement has the temple of God with idols? For we are the temple of the living God; just as God said, "I will dwell in them and walk among them; and I will be their God, and they shall be My people. "Therefore, come out from their midst and be SEPARATE," says the Lord. "and do not touch what is unclean; And I will welcome you. "And I will be a father to you, And you shall be sons and daughters to Me," Says the Lord Almighty. (2 Corinthians 6:14-18 NASB)

    Yet, like Merton who claimed that there is no reason to believe that God has not revealed himself to other religions, and that believers can benefit from being 'open' to other religious traditions, Nouwen's ecumenical views are seen all through his writings. For example (All Emphasis Added)

      "Today I personally believe that while Jesus came to open the door to God's house, all human beings can walk through that door, whether they know about Jesus or not. Today I see it as my call to help every person claim his or her own way to God. Today I see it as my call to help every person claim his or her own way to God." [03]

      In the house of God there are many mansions. There is a place for everyone - a unique special place" [04]

      Still, when we remain faithful to our discipline, even if it is only ten minutes a day, we gradually come to see — by the candlelight of our prayers — that there is a space within us where God dwells and where we are invited to dwell with God... One of the discoveries we make (in contemplative) prayer is that the closer we come to God, the closer we come to all our brothers and sisters in the human family. God is not a private God. The God who dwells in our inner sanctuary is also the God who dwells in the inner sanctuary of each human being. [05]

    Regarding the last quote above, it is a tragic fact that so many Christian contemplatives have adopted and adapted the Hindus and New Age beliefs that we are all connected to an impersonal energy force, which is god - the Ultimate Reality. Because we are all part of this life force we too are god. However, since most of humanity is unaware of this fact, mankind's greatest need is to discover their own divinity - to look inside and find what the Catholic mystics call our true or higher self. Meditation that leads to an altered states of consciousness is the most commonly used method to achieve awareness of our god-selves or god-consciousness.

    Sue Monk Kidd, a well known New Ager who promotes worship of the goddess, wrote the foreword to the second edition of Nouwen's With Open Hands. In her book The Dance of the Dissident Daughter, which is a quest for the "Sacred Feminine" within Christianity, Sue Monk Kidd wrote,

      Today I remember that event for the radiant mystery it was, how I felt myself embraced by Goddess, how I felt myself in touch with the deepest thing I am. It was the moment when, as playwright and poet Ntozake Shange put it, ‘I found god in myself/ and I loved her/ I loved her fiercely'. [06]

    See Feminism and The Bible


    Whatever Happened to Discernment?
    These aberrant views (and there are plenty more - See Below) seem not to have had the slightest effect on Nouwen's popularity among Christians. His books have sold millions of copies in over 28 languages. An excerpt from A Time of Departing [2nd edition] by Ray Yungen states (Emphasis Added).

      Like Merton, Nouwen combines a strong devotion to God with a poetic, comforting, yet distinctly intellectual style that strikes a strong and sympathetic chord with what could be called Christian intelligentsia. Many pastors and professors are greatly attracted to his deep thinking. In fact, one of his biographers revealed that in a 1994 survey of 3,400 U.S. Protestant church leaders, Nouwen ranked second only to Billy Graham in influence among them. Nouwen also attracts many lay people who regard him as very inspirational. One person told me that Nouwen's appeal could be compared to that of motherhood - a warm comforting embrace that leaves you feeling good". [07]

    And, as far as the so called Christian intelligentsia is concerned, apparently even they seem not to be able to separate the wheat from the chaff. One has to wonder at the level of deception in the church today when even seminaries and numerous so called Christian leaders can study and promote the teachings of a Catholic mystic who, like others of his ilk (Thomas Keating, Thomas Merton, Brennan Manning, Richard Foster etc.- the list is a very long one), derived many of his ideas not from the Bible, but from other religions and the mysticism of the east.

    Theological Seminaries: In an article entitled The Dangers of Spiritual Formation and Spiritual Disciplines, Pastor Bob DeWaay tells of a friend and co-worker of his who, in the summer of 2005, went back to seminary (Bethel Theological Seminary in Arden Hills, MN) to finish his masters degree. In the words of his friend(Emphasis Added)

      "I recently took a seminary course on the book of Luke. It was a summer intensive and was one of only two classes being offered at the time. About midway through the week, while the class was steeped in trying to discern the intent and significance of the book of Luke, we began to hear the echoes of mystic chanting coming through the walls. As it turned out, the other class being offered was parked right next to ours. The paper thin walls were carrying the choruses of a class exploring the life and teachings of Catholic mystic Henry Nouwen. We proceeded, trying to concentrate on studying the Scriptures while tuning out the chants that were carrying on next door. Perhaps what was more unsettling though is the class studying Nouwen was chock full, while there were plenty of empty seats next door for anyone wanting to learn about the inspired book of Luke. [08]

    Mike Yaconelli co-founder of Youth Specialties, an international organization which trains and equips youth workers around the globe, says Henri Nouwen's In the Name of Jesus, was one of the two most pivotal book in his life. (The other book being When the Heart Waits by the aforementioned Sue Monk Kidd).[09]

    Ravi Zacharias:
    Henri Nouwen seems to be rather favorably among the staff at Ravi Zacharias International Ministries and, indeed, by Ravi himself.

    In The Greatest Investment, posted on September 2, 2016, Ravi Zacharias mentions reading a book by Nouwen. Also see September 11, 2001: Was God Present or Absent? by Ravi Zacharias

    Jill Carattini, ordained as a specialized minister in the Reformed Church of America, is managing editor of A Slice of Infinity, a daily reading on themes from theology and culture to philosophy and the arts. Several of her articles on rzim.org, including Free Lunch Economy written in 2011, Picnics and Pilgrims and As Sure as the Sun either favorably mention Henri Nouwen, or quotes from one of his many books. 

    Danielle DuRant, Director of Research and Writing, also has at least one article A Disquieting Parable in which she quotes Nouwen's The Return of the Prodigal Son which, by the way is available on Ravi Zacharias web site, along with many others. SEE

    Additionally, numerous books by Nouwen and other Catholic Contemplative are available in Zacharias' online "Christian" book store HERE


    Henri Nouwen and Contemplative Prayer
    Henri Nouwen's book In the Name of Jesus is supposedly a guide to Christian Leadership that is based not on one's own self interests, i.e. power, popularity, control, but on service and sacrifice. Rick Warren said this about the book,

      My wife, Kay, recommends this book: "It's a short book, but it hits at the heart of the minister. It mentions the struggles common to those of us in ministry: the temptation to be relevant, spectacular and powerful. I highlighted almost every word!" [10].

    The problem is that In the Name of Jesus blatantly promotes contemplative prayer. In it Nouwen writes

      Through the discipline of contemplative prayer, Christian leaders have to learn to listen again and again to the voice of [God] ... For Christian leadership to be truly fruitful in the future, a movement from the moral to the mystical is required. [Pgs 31-32]

    Besides which, In the Name of Jesus lists a number of books of 'related interest' including William Shannon's Silence on Fire that "incorporates spiritual insights from the East as well as the West" and another with the unbelievable title of The Zen Teachings of Jesus.

    Note: If you imagine that modern mystics like Thomas Keating, Henri Nouwen, Thomas Merton and a raft of others have some sort of special connection to the Father by way of their contemplative practices, chances are you either have not taken the time to find out what is behind these practices and the people that teach it. For an in-depth look at Contemplative prayer See HERE

    In The Way of the Heart Henri Nouwen quoted John Climacus - abbot of the monastery of Catherine on Mount Sinai in the latter half of the sixth century. The quote was taken from a book by Irénée Hausherr a 20th century Jesuit who was said to be a specialist in Hesychasm - a mystical tradition of contemplative prayer. The quote reads as follows (All Emphasis Added)

      "When you pray do not try to express yourself in fancy words, for often it is the simple repetitious phrases of a little child that our Father in heaven finds most irresistible. Do not strive for verbosity lest your mind be distracted from devotion by a search for words. One phrase on the lips of the tax collector was enough to win God's mercy; one humble request made with faith was enough to save the good thief. Wordiness in prayer often subjects the mind to fantasy and dissipation; single words of their very nature tend to concentrate the mind. When you find satisfaction or compunction in a certain word of your prayer, stop at that point."

    Nouwen then elaboratesCP Nouwen 2

      The quiet repetition of a single word can help us to descend with the mind into the heart .. a word or sentence repeated frequently an

      help us concentrate, to move to the center, to create an inner stillness and thus to listed to to the voice of God... This way of simple prayer, when we are faithful to it and practice it at regular times, slowly leads us to an experience of rest and opens us to God's active presence. [11]

    While I cannot be completely sure which of John Climacus' writings this was paraphrased from, it sounds very like a paragraph in The Ladder of Divine Ascent that was initially written for monastics, but now considered one of the classics - especially in the orthodox church. According to OrthodoxWiki "The aim of the treatise is to be a guide for practicing a life completely and wholly devoted to God. The ladder metaphor - not dissimilar to the vision that the Patriarch Jacob received - is used to describe how one may ascend into heaven by first renouncing the world and finally ending up in heaven with God. There are thirty chapters; each covers a particular vice or virtue. [12]

    However, Climacus said absolutely nothing about "single words". He did not say, or even imply that "a single word can help us to descend with the mind into the heart". Much to the contrary, he was advocating short and simple prayers that are as concise and uncomplicated as possible.  In his words...

      Pray in all simplicity. The publican and the prodigal son were reconciled to God by a single utterance.... In your prayers there is no need for high-flown words, for it is the simple and unsophisticated babblings of children that have often won the heart of the Father in heaven. Try not to talk excessively in your prayer, in case your mind is distracted by the search for words.

      One word from the publican sufficed to placate God, and a single utterance saved the thief. Talkative prayer (polylogia) frequently distracts the mind and deludes it, whereas brevity (monologia) makes for concentration. If it happens that, as you pray, some word evokes delight or remorse within you, linger over it. [13]

    In other words, in the effort to show that Contemplative Prayer is an ancient 'Christian' tradition (albeit completely unknown to the Scriptures, both Nouwen and  Hausherr and saw exactly what they wanted to see in the writings of the ancient authors.

    This is a very similar situation to when John Main, a 20th century Roman Catholic priest who learned his meditation techniques from a Hindu guru, conveniently read into John Cassian's writings what he wanted to find there. Cassian was a 4th century monk from Bethlehem who wrote two major spiritual works, the Institutes and the Conferences. If you actually read Cassian's tenth conference for yourself, you will find that far from advocating a word or phrase to "achieve the stillness necessary for prayer", Cassian was advocating the use of a verse from Psalm 70 in exactly the same way the original author appeared to have used it. See Is Contemplative Prayer -rooted in the tradition of the Desert Fathers or Eastern mysticism

    Meaningless Repetition
    In any case, how Nouwen could advocate "The quiet repetition of a single word" is beyond me when this is EXACTLY what the Lord told us not to do

      "And when you are praying, do not use meaningless repetition as the Gentiles do, for they suppose that they will be heard for their many words.  (Matthew 6:7 NASB)

    Jesus then immediately gave us 'The Lord's Prayer' - an outline of how we should pray. Odd isn't it that the only example of prayer given by the Messiah says not one word about clearing your mind but focuses instead on the kind of thing we need to talk to the Father about?

    Although Nouwen calls the "quiet repetition of a single word" a "short prayer", it is not really a prayer at all. Repeating a word or phrase over and over again is nothing but the 'Christianized' version of the mantra. Much energy has been expended in the effort to show that the sacred word is NOT a Mantra that is one of the primary methods for achieving an altered state of consciousness. But if you cut through the stream of gobbledygook, there is absolutely no difference. For Details See Contemplative Prayer - Chapter II.


    Nouwen and Eastern Religions
    There is an old saying "A man is known by the company he keeps". In other words, our character is reflected in our choice of friends. I would expand this slightly by adding that our character is not only reflected in our 'friends', but also in who we admire and approve of. People not only tend to associate with those who are like them, but endorse those who have similar beliefs, ideas, and opinions. In view of which I would like to take a quick look at some of the people and books that Henri Nouwen expressed approval of.
     

    Nouwen and Fr. Thomas Ryan
    The book Disciplines for Christian Living: Interfaith Perspectives was written by another Catholic priest - Fr. Thomas Ryan, CSP (Community of St. Paul). An editorial review says (All Emphasis Added])

      Ryan, a Roman Catholic priest who spent a year in India studying Hindu, Buddhist, and Islamic spiritual practice, has written a splendid book of practical spirituality, the result of genuine, faithful, and receptive interfaith dialog. Beautifully blending what he learned from those traditions with Christianity, Ryan provides a guide to holistic living, emphasizing the importance of intimate friendship, sabbath time, play and exercise, contemplation, fasting, and service. [14]

    Of this book Henri Nouwen said

      Back Cover:
      I am convinced that this book will be of great help and support to the many people who have a deep faith in Jesus but are at a loss when they look for ways to practice it in their busy and always changing lives. 

      Foreword:
      When Thomas Ryan took a sabbatical and went to India to study the religions of the Hindus, the Buddhists and the Moslems, he was most struck by their practices. In India he came to realize that there was nothing wrong with the How to do it?" question and that all the great Hindu, Buddhist and Moslem teachers taught their disciples very practical disciplines to transform their lives. He became deeply convinced that unless Christians offer similar disciplines, the Christian faith will never become a truly transforming faith, with concrete and specific implications for daily life....

      Living in Toronto and seeing new Hindu and Buddhist temples and new mosques and synagogues being built all over the place, I realize that the east and the west are no longer so far away from each other as before. Even without a far journey we can become aware of the many treasures that different religions have to offer us".

    See Footnote I for one rather pointless and annoying aspect of Thomas Ryan's book

    Nouwen and Andrew Harvey
    In his autobiographical book, Sabbatical Journey. Nouwen spoke glowingly of his April 1996 encounter with author and lecturer Andrew Harvey. Nouwen wrote that it was an opportunity to meet this spiritual writer whose life and work had "intrigued" Nouwen from the moment he heard about him. Nouwen described the lecture he attended as "excellent" and says he later introduced himself to Andrew and asked for his autograph. He further added that although Andrew's "personal and intellectual history" differed from his own, he had the deep sense of meeting a "soul-friend". On the way home, he and two friends, discussed how Andrew's mysticism had "touched" them. [15]

     So who is Andrew Harvey? According to Living Spiritual Teachers Project, (All Emphasis Added)

      Andrew Harvey was born in South India and lived there until at age nine he was sent to England for his education. He studied history at Oxford and at 21 became the youngest person ever to be awarded a fellowship to All Souls College, England's highest academic honor. In 1977, however, he became disillusioned with life at Oxford and the patriarchal, rationalist Western tradition and returned to India.

      India, with its rich diversity of spiritual expressions, shaped his understanding of the value and unity of all religions. His spiritual search initially led him to the ashram of the Bengali mystic Sri Aurobindo. Later, he studied with the Tibetan Buddhist master Thuksey Rinpoche, an experience he recounted in his first spiritual autobiography, Journey to Ladakh. This was followed by a ten-year exploration of the mystical works of the thirteenth century Persian poet Rumi and the Sufi tradition. [16] Note: Rinpoche is an honorific title meaning "precious one"

    Also Note: At the time of the encounter, Harvey had already written Hidden Journey -that details his spiritual surrender to the Indian mystic Mother Meera. See Footnote II for a little about his other book Four Spiritual Guides.


    Nouwen and Eknath Easwaran
    Eknath Easwaran is a spiritual teacher, prolific author and founder of the nonprofit Blue Mountain Center of Meditation in Berkeley, CA founded in 1961. His many books include one on the Bhagavad Gita, one on the Upanishads, and a translation of an important Buddhist text The Dhammapada - the path of truth, harmony, and righteousness. He is also the author of God Makes the Rivers to Flow: An Anthology of the World's Sacred Poetry and Prose and The Mantram Handbook

    Easwaran believed that all the wisdom traditions of the world have their own great spiritual passages that convey our highest ideals and the qualities we most admire. Meditating on these texts cause these qualities to come alive in the meditator. In yet another of his books  - Meditation: A Simple Eight-Point Program for Translating Spiritual Ideals into Daily Life - Easwaran recommended passages for meditation from every major spiritual tradition - the prayer of St. Francis, excerpts from the Sutta Nipata (a Buddhist scripture), the Psalms, the Bhagavad Gita, 'Baba Kuhi' (an Iranian Sufi poet-saint), and Swami Omkar (a Karma Yogi) etc.

     Yet, on the back cover, Henri Nouwen claimed that ...

      "This book has helped me a great deal"

    Be Still
    On page 163 Easwaran takes a Bible verse completely out of context.. saying

      ".. to realize God we must quiet the mind. As the Bible says, "Be still and know that I am God" [17]

    While Easwaran was not a Christian, he was doing what many thousands of people (Christians and non-Christians alike) around the world do, i.e. twist the plain meaning of Scripture to conform to their philosophical outlook. This verse from Psalm 46 has absolutely nothing to do with quieting the mind to realize God. See Contemplative Prayer - Unsupported By Scripture

    Two or Three
    On page 45 Easwaran wrote that it is "good to meditate with others". Either families can meditate together or

      "two or three friends can gather together in one home for morning and evening meditation. You will remember that Jesus said, "Where two or three come together in  my name, I am present among them"

    Easwaran is quoting Matthew 18:20 which is a terribly misinterpreted passage of Scripture even among believers. In fact, as Tyler S. Ramey says "there are a couple of aspects to Christ's words in the immediate context of the passage that are worthy of comment since they are frequently misapplied."

    So what does it mean when Jesus said "where two or three come together in my name, there am I with them"? DETAILS


    The Kingdom of God
    On page 29, the author wrote

      Attaining this state of consciousness is the highest goal we can have in life. Different religions have called it by different names: illumination, enlightenment, nirvana, Self-realization, entering the promised land or the kingdom of heaven within. But whatever the language, the experience is everywhere the same. Jesus called it "a pearl of great price," Without it, our lives will always be wanting; even if we had to give everything on earth to obtain it, the cost would not be too high. May this pearl be yours! [18]

    Does the Bible teach that the Kingdom of God is within human beings? Although the King James and the NIV use the phrase "the kingdom of God is within you", the context favors the NASB translation that says

      Now having been questioned by the Pharisees as to when the kingdom of God was coming, He answered them and said, "The kingdom of God is not coming with signs to be observed; nor will they say, 'Look, here it is!' or, 'There it is!' For behold, the kingdom of God is in your midst." (Luke 17:20-21 NASB)

    Yet, once again, a Catholic priest did not recognize a clear fallacy.

    he theme of the entire Bible makes it impossible that Jesus was telling the Pharisees who were His enemies, that the kingdom was within them. What He was saying was that the beginning of this three stage kingdom was among them in the person of Jesus Christ. If they were going to enter the kingdom, they would have to repent and turn to Christ for salvation (see Mark 1:14, 15). There is absolutely nothing in this passage that would suggest that if the Pharisees took an inward journey using meditative techniques they would find God's kingdom!" See The Kingdom - When?

    As said earlier, the kingdom of God that Jesus said he was sent to proclaim is not some mystical altered state of consciousness, but a real life kingdom that matches, in every respect, the world most men and women would choose to live in. A place of peace and safety, where there is no crime, hunger and disease, war and above all... no death. Far from being outdated, out of touch, and largely irrelevant to modern society, Christianity promises exactly the utopian world most men and women can only dream of.. See The Message of The Bible - Part 13 of Choose Life That You Might Live.

    See Context is CRUCIAL
    No Biblical author simply strung together a number of lofty sounding phrases disconnected from one another. Since each verse is an integral part of a particular point the author was trying to make, no one should read, much less base their beliefs on, stand alone verses. The reader can only be accurately informed by God's Word the way it is written - in its context. Understanding what the author meant comes not only from the words he wrote, but also by what the overall message of the chapter is intended to convey. But, since this takes a little more time, study and effort, most Christians are content with allowing a verse to be wrested from it's context, and used to convey whatever meaning the speaker/author wishes it to convey which, all too often, is nothing but a corruption of the truth. This perversion of Scriptures is done (whether intentionally or unintentionally) in order to persuade men that whatsoever the false teacher says is based on Biblical truth.


    Nouwen - Homosexuality

    In God's Beloved: A Spiritual Biography of Henri Nouwen by Michael O'Laughlin, he says

      In addition to being sensitive and prone to self-doubt, Henri slowly came to an uneasy awareness that he was homosexual, and this can hardly have added to his sense of well-being. ... In the thirties, forties and fifties, homosexuality was a feared, even loathsome aberration, part sin, part mental illness. No one talked about it except as a joke of an insult... He knew he was not like other people and that he did not dare reveal this truth about himself. [19]

    While there is absolutely no evidence that Nouwen was anything but celibate.. the Biography Of Henri Nouwen by Michael Ford says

      Before he died in 1996, Nouwen was becoming more vocal in his support of gay men and women, saying they had a "unique vocation in the Christian community." (See Section on Homosexuality)

    Additionally, it seems that Nouwen was not exactly stable.

      Nouwen was extraordinarily generous, giving money to various causes and sending flowers and gifts to his many friends. Sometimes, however, friends backed away because he could be so demanding. When his close friend Nathan Ball, the director of Daybreak, began to pull back from their platonic relationship, Nouwen went into a tailspin and had to seek treatment for an emotional breakdown. [20]


    Nouwen' Strange Fascination with Vincent Van Gogh
    The cover of Nouwen's book Life of the Beloved is Vincent Van Gogh's painting entitled Café Terrace at Night. Sabbatical Journey features Sunflowers (2) another of the artists paintings. Additionally, the Henry Nouwen web site used to feature different paintings by Vincent Van Gogh at the top of individual pages. In answer to the question of why they used Van Gogh as a motif, they replied (Emphasis Added)

      "Henri Nouwen was deeply moved and inspired by the life and work of van Gogh. Of van Gogh he said, "That was [Van Gogh's] vocation: to touch people by tenderly expressing his solidarity with the human condition - not motivated by anger but by love." Nouwen wrote and taught a course at Yale Divinity School in 1977 entitled "The Ministry of Vincent van Gogh"."

    While I do think that some of Van Gogh's art was interesting, I cannot see how a so called spiritual leader could ever be 'inspired' by his life... What exactly in this sordid tale is there to find inspiration in? He had a ministry? What ministry? Van Gogh is almost as famous for his mental instability as for his vivid paintings.Very possibly over-indulged in absinthe (alcohol content - 55-75 percent) and eventually killed himself.

    At one stage of his life he moved in with a pregnant prostitute called Sien Hoornik and even considered marrying her. He suffered from various types of epilepsy, psychotic attacks, and delusions, once committing himself to an asylum. His mental state deteriorated through much of his life with him once cutting off his own ear and taking it to a brothel, where he asked for a prostitute named Rachel and handed the ear to her, asking her to keep it carefully. At the age of 37, Van Gogh shot himself in the chest and died two days later.

    Debate has raged over the years as to the source of Van Gogh's mental illness and its effect on his work. Some of the theories which have been suggested include schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, syphilis, poisoning from swallowed paints, and temporal lobe epilepsy. Any of these could have been the culprit and been aggravated by malnutrition, overwork, a fondness for the alcoholic beverage absinthe, and insomnia.


    Conclusion
    In his book God's Beloved: A Spiritual Biography of Henri Nouwen, Michael O'Laughlin says

       "Nouwen's approach to spirituality was certainly unique and personal", his "way of speaking and writing grew out of an awareness that I feel is more typically artistic than theological... and perhaps the artist's way of seeing and creating became Nouwen's way of doing spirituality." [21]

    You can say that again..

    Everyone is entitled to "do spirituality" any way they choose.

    However, God has already outlined everything we need to know in His book - people cannot and will not escape the consequences of ignoring what He has to say or endeavoring to blaze their own path to Him. Certainly every single person who names the name of Christ is obliged to follow God's teachings as outlined in the Scriptures.

    If you do not wish to do so, it is your God-given right to freedom of choice.

    However, please call yourself anything you choose - just not a "Christian", because you aren't one - not by any stretch of the imagination.. See Can We Decide How to Approach God? and Does God Dwell Within Us? on THIS page..

    Although Henri Nouwen might have been a wonderful friend to many people and befriended hundreds more (things one can certainly admire him for), the fact remains that, with his ecumenical leanings, his embracing of eastern religious practices  and his promotion of pagan 'spiritual' books, he undoubtedly led very many people astray. I dread to think of how many believers were introduced to New Age and Eastern religious ideas they may never have heard of before.

    In the ultimate analysis, Henri Nouwen was a wolf in sheep's clothing. I dread to think how many souls were pushed off Christianity's narrow path by him and the people he endorsed.
     

    Bible1-Bar


    Footnote I - A Rather Pointless And Annoying Aspect of Thomas Ryan's book
    Although there is much to condemn in this book (endless discussions about the different forms of Buddhist meditation for example), one of the extremely annoying and rather pointless aspects is when Thomas Ryan continuously extols the virtues of Islam, particularly how it harmonizes the material and spiritual aspects of life - and how "every member of society is expected to willingly and gladly help those who are in need..." Pg. 200. He also says,

      The Muslim code assumes responsibility for the orphans, widows and the poor who slip through the cracks of Arab society... Unless one has heeded the cry of the beggars, "Alms for the love of Allah," one will have a thin defense on the Day of Judgment. Islam does not preach salvation by faith alone. Only those who do the truth come to the light. Pg. 229.

    So why exactly did Ryan fit to hold up pagan religions as examples we need to emulate when there are over 25 references in the Old Testament (written centuries before Islam was even dreamed of) as to how the widow and orphan are to be treated. For example,

      "The Levite, because he has no portion or inheritance among you, and the alien, the orphan and the widow who are in your town, shall come and eat and be satisfied, in order that the Lord your God may bless you in all the work of your hand which you do.  (Deuteronomy 14:29 NASB)

    In regard to the injustices being perpetrated by the nation of Israel, the Lord God had this to say

      "I hate, I reject your festivals, Nor do I delight in your solemn assemblies. "Even though you offer up to Me burnt offerings and your grain offerings, I will not accept them; And I will not even look at the peace offerings of your fatlings. "Take away from Me the noise of your songs; I will not even listen to the sound of your harps. "But let justice roll down like waters And righteousness like an ever-flowing stream. (Amos 5:21-24 NASB)

    James, the brother of Christ said this

      Pure and undefiled religion in the sight of our God and Father is this: to visit orphans and widows in their distress, and to keep oneself unstained by the world. (James 1:27 NASB)

      What use is it, my brethren, if someone says he has faith but he has no works? Can that faith save him? If a brother or sister is without clothing and in need of daily food, and one of you says to them, "Go in peace, be warmed and be filled," and yet you do not give them what is necessary for their body, what use is that? Even so faith, if it has no works, is dead, being by itself. But someone may well say, "You have faith and I have works; show me your faith without the works, and I will show you my faith by my works." You believe that God is one. You do well; the demons also believe, and shudder. But are you willing to recognize, you foolish fellow, that faith without works is useless? (James 2:14-20 NASB)

    See The Myth of Faith Alone:
    I dread to think what would happen if someone in a modern church were to preach that you have to attain a certain level of righteousness to be saved. The hue and cry would be deafening, with the preacher soundly denounced, from one end of the Christian world to the other, as a false teacher who is teaching salvation by works. But, consider for a moment Jesus' words in the sermon on the mount.... ""For I say to you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the scribes and Pharisees, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven". (Matthew 5:20 NASB) 

    [PLACE IN TEXT]


    Footnote II -  Four Spiritual Guides

    Andrew Harvey is also the author of Walk with Four Spiritual Guides: Krishna, Buddha, Jesus and Ramakrishna. Since this book was writtenCP Nouwen Harvey years after Harvey and Henri Nouwen met, it may not seem particularly relevant to their relationship. However, it simply shows the mindset of the person whom Nouwen asked for an autograph. In any case - I cannot resist bringing up the following piece of nonsense that Harvey wrote,

      Many writers treat Krishna as a figure of mythology and question whether such a historical personage every existed; or else they say he was a human hero who was later divinized. A similar controversy is taking place about the historical Jesus versus the mythic Christ. In both cases - and especially in Krishna's, since his advent was so long ago - it is not possible to establish the facts in terms of contemporary methodology. History and legend are now bound too closely to untangle.

      On the other hand, just as Christian tradition holds that the Gospel accounts were inspired by the Holy Spirit and are not merely the product of their human authors, so too, according to the Vedic tradition, the testimonials of the seers regarding Krishna's advent are based on mystical knowledge that is not merely fanciful exaggeration of facts but rather a deeper insight into reality arising from advanced states of consciousness" [22]

    The level of ignorance in the above quote is mind boggling.

    Christian tradition in no way holds holds that the Gospel accounts came about because they were inspired by the Holy Spirit. While the Spirit may have prompted some aspects, if one actually reads what they wrote, they authors were very clear that three of them were themselves eyewitnesses to Jesus' ministry. For example...

      Peter stated that they "did not follow cleverly devised tales", but were eyewitnesses of Christ's majesty. And that they themselves heard God's voice from heaven when they were with Jesus on the holy mountain. (2 Peter 1:16, 18)

      John said they were testifying to what they had seen with their eyes, what they had looked at and touched with their hands. (1 John 1:1), and referring to the crucifixion, said "he who has seen has testified, and his testimony is true... "(John 19:35)

    The one exception was the Gentile Luke who was not a firsthand eyewitness to Jesus' ministry. However, as he said, after carefully investigating everything, he compiled an account of things handed down by those who were eyewitnesses from the beginning. And that it seemed fitting to him to write these accounts out in consecutive order (Luke 1:1-4).

    This is a far cry from "the testimonials of the seers regarding Krishna's advent are based on mystical knowledge that is not merely fanciful exaggeration of facts but rather a deeper insight into reality arising from advanced states of consciousness"

    Incidentally, the only evidence presented for Krishna being a historical figure is extremely thin. Past astronomical phenomena, and the discovery of two underwater settlements (near the modern day city of Dwarka off the coast of Gujarat in India) which are believed to correspond with the two Dwarkas associated with Krishna in the Mahabharata are about it. On the other hand,

    Although many, if not most, non-Christians assume that Christianity is a "blind faith" - that Christians ignore reality and have unquestioning loyalty to an absolute belief system without proof or evidence, this is light years away from the truth.

    In reality, the Christian faith is a commitment based on evidence. This evidence includes the Bible's humanly impossible authorship, fulfilled prophecy, and it's archaeological and scientific accuracy... none of which are seen in the books of other religions. In fact, it is quite remarkable as to how many times, God, Jesus, and the prophets of both the Old and New Testaments, appealed to facts to support what they said and taught.

    However, the Christian position only asks that the same criteria used to judge the truth of other ancient documents, that told us about people and events of the past, be applied to the Bible. See God and His Bible And The Reliability of The New Testament - chapters 4 and 7 of Choose Life That You May Live[PLACE IN TEXT]


    End Notes. Henri Nouwen
    [01] Henri Nouwen Society. About Henri http://www.henrinouwen.org/henri/about/

    [02] Michael O'Laughlin. God's Beloved: A Spiritual Biography of Henri Nouwen. Publisher: Orbis Books (September 3, 2004) Page 178.

    [03] Henri Nouwen. Sabbatical Journey: The Diary of His Final Year – September 1, 2000. Publisher: The Crossroad Publishing Company (September 1, 2000) Pg. 51

    [04] Henri Nouwen. Life of the Beloved - p. 53

    [05] Henri Nouwen. Here And Now. 1994. Publisher: New York: Crossroad Publishing Pgs. 24 -25

    [06] The Dance of the Dissident Daughter: A Woman's Journey from Christian Tradition to the Sacred Feminine. Publisher: HarperOne; Rev Upd edition (September 20, 2016) Pg. 158)

    [07] Ray Yungen - Henri Nouwen and Buddhism. Excerpt from A Time of Departing, 2nd ed.
    http://www.lighthousetrailsresearch.com/nouwenbuddhism.htm

    [08] Bob DeWaay . The Dangers of Spiritual Formation and Spiritual Disciplines. A Critique of Dallas Willard and The Spirit of the Disciplines.  Critical Issues Commentary. http://cicministry.org/commentary/issue91.htm

    [09] A Conversation With Mike Yaconelli. Interviewed by Michael J. Cusick Copyright © 1995 Mars Hill Review 2 May 1995 · Issue No. 2: pgs 67-87. http://www.leaderu.com/marshill/mhr02/yacon1.html

    [10] Rick Warren quoting Kay Warren on the Ministry Toolbox (Issue #54, 6/5/2002)

    [11] Henri Nouwen, The Way of the Heart (New York: Ballantine Books, 1981), Pg. 81-82

    [12] OrthodoxWiki. The Ladder of Divine Ascent. https://orthodoxwiki.org/The_Ladder_of_Divine_Ascent

    [13] John Climacus: The Ladder of Divine Ascent. Translated by Colm Luibheid and Norman Russell. Publisher: Paulist Pr (December 1982) Page 44

    [14] Reed Business Information. Editorial Review See Amazon page
    https://www.amazon.com/Disciplines-Christian-Living-Interfaith-Perspectives/dp/0809133806

    [15] Henri Nouwen. Sabbatical Journey: The Diary of His Final Year. Publisher: The Crossroad Publishing Company (September 1, 2000).
    Pg 149

    [16] Living Spiritual Teachers Project - Andrew Harvey. http://www.spiritualityandpractice.com/explorations/teachers/view/56

    [17] Eknath Easwaran. Meditation: A Simple Eight-Point Program for Translating Spiritual Ideals into Daily Life Publisher: Nilgiri (1996)

    [18] ibid. Pg. 28

    [19] Michael O'Laughlin. God's Beloved: A Spiritual Biography of Henri Nouwen Publisher: Orbis Books (September 3, 2004) Page 81.

    [20] Review of Biography Of Henri Nouwen by Michael Ford. John Mark Ministries. http://www.jmm.org.au/articles/4673.htm

    [21] Michael O'Laughlin. God's Beloved: A Spiritual Biography of Henri Nouwen Publisher: Orbis Books (September 3, 2004). Page 17

    [22] Andrew Harvey. Walk with Four Spiritual Guides: Krishna, Buddha, Jesus and Ramakrishna. Publisher: SkyLight Paths; 1 edition (March 3, 2003) Pg. 13-14

    www.inplainsite.org

    Mysticism-Back

    Index to
    Contemplative Prayer - The Pioneers